See how your reported results read as versioned evidence records β linked to experiments and limitations.Know what the science actually supports before you trust the answer.
Press Enter β΅ to review claims
Explore by Goal
"For me, it is far better to grasp the Universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring."
- Carl Sagan
Quick Explanation
Copied
Martine Billard β evidence-backed focus on the βtetraspanin webβ
Across multiple highly cited papers, her work maps how tetraspanins (esp. CD9/CD81 and partners) organize membrane complexes and regulate immunology-relevant signaling and cleavage events, including links to cholesterol and palmitoylation (, , , , ).
Raw βworks_countβ per year as supplied in the prompt. This is descriptive only; it does not measure impact or rigor per paper.
2) Core mechanistic storyline (what these cited works collectively support)
Working model repeatedly targeted:
Physical association of tetraspanins into surface networks connected to other membrane proteins (supporting a βtetraspanin webβ as more than correlation).
Stability control of tetraspaninβtetraspanin interactions via lipid modifications such as palmitoylation.
Membrane environment coupling, especially cholesterolβtetraspanin links, as a potential driver of physical/functional behavior.
Downstream functional consequences for immunology-linked processes, including regulation of cleavage events through ADAM10-mediated pathways.
Key cited primary studies (examples from the provided top works list)
Claim strength: association/network mapping connecting tetraspanins to HLA-DR and VLA integrins.
Skeptical note: Network/association claims depend heavily on experimental design (e.g., detergent conditions, co-immunoprecipitation specificity, and controls). The record provided here does not include methodological details, so confidence about mechanism must remain moderate.
CD9/CD81 functional partner framework
Claim strength: partner-centric model for major molecular partners of CD9 and CD81 within tetraspan systems.
Skeptical note: Partner identification can be context-dependent (cell type, expression levels, and experimental perturbations). Without the full methods here, generality across tissues remains an empirical question.
Claim strength: provides a mechanistic lipid link for maintaining/influencing interaction networks.
Skeptical note: Lipid-modification effects can arise indirectly (protein localization, membrane microdomain partitioning). The record indicates a role of palmitoylation, but does not show magnitude, replicates, or causal sufficiency.
Cholesterol physical + functional linkage to tetraspanins
Claim strength: connects membrane cholesterol environment with tetraspanin behavior.
Skeptical note: Cholesterol perturbations often have pleiotropic membrane effects; causal attribution to tetraspanins specifically requires careful controls (not included in the provided record).
Tetraspanins regulate ADAM10-mediated cleavage of TNF-Ξ± and EGF
Claim strength: bridges βweb organizationβ to a downstream enzymatic signaling outcome.
Skeptical note: Cleavage readouts depend on expression levels, substrate availability, and protease activity measurements. Without the full experimental detail here, effect direction and mechanism specificity cannot be fully validated from the prompt record alone.
3) Cross-paper consistency check (what βhangs togetherβ vs what is uncertain)
Consistency (stronger evidence pattern)
Complex-network framing repeatedly appears (tetraspanins as organizers into a surface web) with connectivity to immune-relevant membrane proteins ().
Lipid and microenvironment coupling is explored mechanistically (palmitoylation and cholesterol) in separate studies, which is internally coherent: lipid modifications can affect membrane organization and receptor complex stability (, ).
Functional translation appears via an effector pathway (ADAM10-mediated cleavage), indicating the work does not stop at complex mapping ().
Uncertainties / blind spots from the provided record
Methodological details are missing in the prompt (e.g., controls for co-complex artifacts, detergent/plasma membrane fraction purity). Association studies can be sensitive to experimental conditions.
Generalization risk: tetraspanin behavior can be cell-type specific (immune vs epithelial vs cancer). The record includes at least one profiling study in colon cancer cells (), but full scope across tissues is not shown here.
Causality granularity: where lipid perturbations and cleavage assays are involved, the mechanistic chain (direct vs indirect effects; sufficiency vs necessity) must be checked study-by-studyβinformation not included in the prompt record.
4) βImpact mapβ of the provided top works list (relative cited-by counts)
This chart is only for the provided top works. It is not a comprehensive view of her entire publication set.
5) What would most improve confidence in βscientific strengthβ for this author?
Retrieve and audit full-text methods/controls for the key association-to-mechanism steps (web assembly, lipid perturbations, and cleavage readouts), then check whether later work converges on the same causal chain.
Quantify robustness: independent replicates, effect sizes, and whether orthogonal assays support each mechanistic claim (not just correlation/co-localization).
Assess reproducibility and context: do the same tetraspanin interactions predict functional outcomes across multiple cell types or only within specific experimental systems?
Explore further on BGPT
Feedback:
Updated: April 30, 2026
BGPT Author Review
Scientific Quality
70%
From the provided top papers, the authorβs work shows a coherent mechanistic focus (tetraspanin web organization β lipid/membrane modulation β downstream functional signaling). The repeated emergence of mechanistic lipid and partner-network claims suggests solid experimental targeting and iterative development. However, the prompt record lacks full-text methodological details, effect sizes, replication structure, and causal sufficiency; association/network claims can be sensitive to experimental conditions. Overall: strong thematic mechanistic coherence with moderate confidence on depth of causality and generalizability from the limited excerpted metadata.
Communication Quality
70%
The publication titles/abstract-level snippets indicate clear mechanistic framing (e.g., cholesterolβtetraspanin, palmitoylation stability, ADAM10 cleavage). Still, this score canβt be fully validated without reading the actual writing, figure narratives, and explanation quality in full text; based on provided metadata only, clarity appears above average but not fully provable here.
Author Novelty
60%
Tetraspanin biology is a well-established field; the novelty here appears to be in specific mechanistic connections (lipid control and downstream cleavage regulation) and specific interaction-network mapping. Without comparing to contemporaneous breakthroughs across the whole field, novelty canβt be rated higher than moderate.
Scientific Rigor
70%
The selected works include mechanistic perturbation angles (palmitoylation, cholesterol link, ADAM10-mediated cleavage), which typically require careful controlsβsuggesting non-trivial rigor. Yet, because full methodological and statistical details are not provided in the prompt, rigor can only be scored as moderately high rather than maximally high.
Build a paper-to-claim graph from the provided Billard works: extract tetraspanin components, lipid modifiers, and downstream functional outputs, then score evidence-causality links for each claim across the set.
Get emailed when your analysis is done!
We'll email you the results when your analysis is finished.
Hypothesis Graveyard
A simple model where tetraspanins only serve as passive co-localization markers (no causal role) is less compelling because at least one provided work explicitly frames regulation of ADAM10-mediated cleavage outcomes as being governed by tetraspanins ().
A model where cholesterol affects ADAM10 cleavage only through global membrane fluidity (with no specific coupling to tetraspanin organization) is weakened by the existence of a paper claiming a physical and functional cholesterolβtetraspanin link, suggesting a more specific coupling mechanism rather than purely physical-fluidity effects ().
Science Art
Science Movie
Make a narrated HD Science movie for this answer ($32 per minute)
Explore by Goal
Quick Explanation
Long Explanation
Ask a Follow-Up
Key Insight
Analysis 
Hypothesis Graveyard
Discussion